The States of Jersey Police have never been great when it comes to major crime. We are a fortunate island and bad stuff doesn’t happen that often but when it does the investigation is normally a mess.
Young Finnish au pair Tuula Hoeoek was found battered to death in a muddy field in December 1966 and her murderer could well be still among us for all the progress that’s been made. The ‘Beast of Jersey’ Edward Paisnel stalked the lanes by night and assaulted and raped children for 14 years before he was apprehended in 1971 – for running a red light.
In November 1993 the world’s Press set up camp at the bar of the former Caesar’s Palace nightspot at Greve de Lecq on Jersey’s north coast. Down the road the bodies of Nicholas and Elizabeth Newall, wrapped in tarpaulin, were being dug up. They say the smell would have knocked out an elephant. They’d been there for six years.
In October 1987 they’d gone missing from their home, having earlier the previous evening enjoyed a meal with their sons Roderick and Mark at the Seacrest, near Corbiere. (Great restaurant that was, now apartments.) The sons, who had returned to England the day after, returned and co-operated with the missing persons enquiry
Months later it turned into a murder enquiry. The remains of a bonfire with blood-stained clothing was discovered nearby. At last a forensic examination was done on the house – extensive blood marks, scrubbed clean, were found. A search for the bodies was now begun and people were marching and poking everywhere for months. Mediums were brought in, and the finest UK search dogs. Nothing. Only when Roderick was trapped into a confession and was arrested and extradited back to Jersey did he lead the police to the bodies.
Roderick served 12 years of his sentence and was released in 2006. Mark, charged only with covering up the murders, served three years.
It’s crazy to think that the “beast of Jersey’ was caught running a red light. Imagine the policeman who caught him, what a story to tell.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes indeed Letizia. Even then if he hadn’t panicked and the police had a closer look at his car, and discovered some bits and pieces, he’d have slipped through their fingers.
LikeLike
On the prowl, how frightening.
LikeLike
The book, ghost-written by Paisnel’s wife Joan, is worth a read.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Will add it to my list, thanks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
….convicted on evidence which was entirely circumstantial and following a trial which had various irregularities.
It is certainly questionable whether he was in fact properly found guilty, in which case the true perpetrator, whoever he might have been, did indeed slip through the fingers of the police.
LikeLike
12 and 3 years for murder? That seems a bit light. Yikes.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Roderick got double life but was clearly a model prisoner.
LikeLike
From double life to twelve years? Wow.
LikeLike
Sounds as thought the folklore of Jersey would be great fodder for a crime writer! Are you thinking of branching out, Roy?
LikeLike
Hi Fran! I’m not sure I have the sharp mind to write good crime. Honestly the hidden aspects of real-life crime here are fascinating. The rarity of serious crime makes it all the more interesting.
LikeLike
Such a gruesome story, Roy. I agree with Carrie, the punishment definitely didn’t fit the crime.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Strangely no one seems to have a bad word for Roderick. Seems to have charmed everyone, including the parole board.
LikeLike
I remember that Newell case. Very odd, and a very light sentence, I think. Where was Bergerac when you needed him?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Jenny. Yes indeed there’s still much that we don’t know about that night. Astonishing though with modern policing methods they let the boys swan away free.
LikeLike
Sounds like the place has some serious history Roy. I am always pleased when mysteries are solved and get frustrated when I read a story and there are no real answers. Thanks for an interesting read.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Kath – yes of course these major incidents impact more in a small community. I find it amazing that the Newall bodies lay undisturbed for six years in a 9×5 island after all the searching, and they were only yards from a popular pub and woodland walks. The full story of that night will never be told unless Roderick chooses.
LikeLike
Interesting stuff, Roy. I guess Jersey is so small and quiet, the police don’t get enough practice to get good at solving major crime (which makes for an interesting debate on which set of circumstances one would prefer).
LikeLiked by 1 person
That is a fact Janna 🙂 The old stereotype is that the unique mix of honorary and uniformed police here destroy any evidence with their big boots before the SOCOs ever get a chance. I do believe we’ve moved on from those days and the force is now very much more professional and the recruits of a far higher calibre than used to be the case. Still we do need mainland expertise on occasion and fortunately our links with the UK are very good.
LikeLike
the stuff of books!! I guess we all have our share of these kind of grisly unsolved crimes. On the westcoast of Canada we had women missing from the streets for ten years before the police got serious. The women were not considered important but their families pursued it. The full horrors were played down but it was a sad sad story ( Robert Pickton- serial killer). PS: will be reading your book now ( I have a list I’m going through and yours is next!)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes indeed Cybele, and so much depends on the resources that the police dept. are prepared to devote to a case. I’m guessing that, quite often, they are directed towards cases that have a good chance of a satisfactory outcome and conviction. Only in crime novels is the driven detective allowed to pursue a case that he/she believes in while other live cases are left to grow cold.
Hope you like AWCM and the bit of whimsy along the way.
LikeLike
Don’t give me nightmares, Roy! I’ll never be able to drive by an empty field without wondering . .. .
LikeLiked by 1 person
That muddy field where they found poor Tuula sure is a bleak and lonely spot Kristine. Poor kid.
LikeLike
It’s interesting when you get a first hand account of cases like this from the police (my cousin was a high profile police officer and he told me of several ‘unsolved’ cases where the police knew exactly who had committed the crime but didn’t have enough evidence to take to court). I have the feeling the police may have suspected who murdered poor Tuula and it would be interesting if someone reopened the case for investigation (or talked to police officers (probably retired) to write a book about it – hint hint). I also wonder why those boys killed their parents – was there ever a reason given??? I’m intrigued…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Dianne, good to hear from you. Sure, us Joe Publics only really get to see what we’re allowed to and 95% of the information isn’t revealed to us. But police in all jurisdictions have never been slow to make the evidence fit their preferred suspect so I’m not so convinced that they really know.
In the Tuula Hoeoek case they re-opened the file and one retired (now dead) detective was certain he’d identified the killer but his findings were examined and dismissed. The poor girl’s parents are still alive I believe.
The Newall boys had plenty of motive – all came to light afterwards really. There was no love lost between sons and parents anyway and the latter were squandering their inheritance. Still it was strange. They were exemplary lads by all accounts. One rush of blood might have explained the first murder but the second was in a separate room. As Nicholas pleaded guilty the full facts were never really examined, maybe for the best.
LikeLike
Very interesting, Roy. I agree that the police can make their minds up pretty quickly as to who they think did it – we’ve had several high profile cases in Australia where they’ve spent so much time focusing on the one person that they miss the rest of the evidence. As far as the Newall boys go – I thought inheritance and or money may have been the reason. What an awful thing to do. I guess the world is made up of all sorts.
LikeLike
It was all very odd Dianne, a horrible mess with even the victims painted as dislikable. It’s quite strange to be near to the various sites of major crime on a daily basis.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m uncomfortable when a ‘bad guy’ gets off that easily from a bad crime. Gives me the creeps.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Pam – well I guess the sentence was right, though he’d have swung 50 years ago.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jersey doesn’t seem as innocent as one might think. These stories brought out the writer in me. Any one of them (or all of them) would make a good novel. Which one would you choose?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Maybe a cue for a novel Julie. Like the Stardust deaths I doubt if I’d have the courage to address the events directly. One of the victims of the delayed capture of the ‘Beast’ was poor old Alphonse Le Gastelois who, as an odd fellow, was singled out for suspicion. To prove his innocence he set up home on the offshore islet of Les Ecrehous for 14 years and, sure enough, the assaults continued in his absence.
LikeLike
Even Alphonse, when interviewed in late 1971, drew no comfort from the conviction of the so-called “Beast”. Indeed, he stated that he believed that the court had convicted the wrong person and he even produced a name of his own. The police of course, were not interested, having “closed the case”.
Indeed, the belated reward which befell Alphonse materialised after the appeal of the “Beast” and took the form of his being dragged back to Jersey under arrest on a trumped up charge of arson.
The jury took just minutes to throw out the case which, interestingly, is about the same time that the Jurats took to convince the “Beast” after having heard five days of complicated evidence and during which extremely short time they should have been considering both the quality of that evidence (such as it was) and the operation of the “similar fact” doctrine.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Indeed I have heard that doubts have been cast about the nature of the conviction. Indeed sad if they got the wrong man. Thank you for your perspective on this.
LikeLike
Roy, I think you’ve got some good inspiration for a crime novel too. I would love to see you write something like that. This blog post was fascinating, and with your Jersey perspective, it would be a unique one indeed.
LikeLike
Thank you Britt. It’s an idea but I think crime writing needs good planning skills which I just don’t possess. Still and all, something to consider…
LikeLiked by 1 person
I still think there is a lot more to the Newalls murders to come out. The hired van the previous day. Did they just have tarpaulins etc lying about? very handy. I understand that a lot of equipment together with the tarpaulins was purchased the previous day but Roderick was not identified, maybe someone else more closely involved?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Ellen, thanks for this. Since writing this post I’ve read ‘Murder in the Family’ by Jeremy Josephs. It’s very good and I don’t think leaves much doubt in the matter.
LikeLike
Like the UK case of the Yorkshire Ripper, serial killer who was only caught on a minor traffic violation! scary stuff!
LikeLike
Oh I didn’t know that about Mr Sutcliffe 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep!
LikeLike
I never met the boys. Nick Newell taught me English at St Michael’s Preparatory school. I thought he was a brilliant teacher and have fond memories of him. He was a strict disciplinarian and meted out hefty punishments in the form of producing 500 words by the next day for misdemeanors! My brother Bob is a just about to retire as a PC of 30 odd years. He racked up some lucrative overtime guarding the site when the bodies were found. My late father met Mark once in his office, soon after the discovery. He told us that he was a very cold fish indeed.
LikeLike
Hi Ned. One of the enduring aspects of the case is how so few people who knew them have ever had anything bad to say against the boys. It’s not that they were thugs, or unstable in any way. Both were well regarded members of society.
Another oddity was the Great Storm a couple of nights later which deflected attention away from the strange events coming to light. I wonder if certain clues might have been identified earlier if police resources hadn’t been diluted – though it was great work in the end which brought a conclusion.
LikeLike
Newall. I had forgotten it was at the time of the great storm.
LikeLike
This was a cold, callous and calculated very deliberate act of murder for parents money. These boys have not shown any remorse, spent the 5 years in wake of the murders, indulging their every whim- purchase of yacht and circling the globe, spending pursuing spent way too little time behind bars, It is appalling the amount of time these pair spent behind bars-It is even more appalling that these young men released back into society should have access to a dime of their parents money.
LikeLike
Thanks Ann, many will agree with you.
LikeLike
These guys did not get a punishment fitting to their crime.
12 years for double murder is pathetic justice and they inherit the parents wealth.
LikeLike
Thanks John, thoughts shared by many.
LikeLike
I have just returned from a trip to Jersey and I thought about the Newall murders when I was at Greve de Lecq. I’ve often wondered what Roderick and Mark are doing now.
LikeLike
Yes I think there is general intrigue into what has become of the boys.
LikeLike